Give Butterson Agency Inc. a shot. You won’t be disappointed.
We are your trusted independent insurance agency.
Home »
Your vehicle, your home, and your family are all important to you, but you may not know how to best protect them. We do all the work to help you find the right coverage for your needs, serving as your insurance advisor.
30+ Years
combined experience
Karen and Katie Butterson are hardworking, caring, and passionate residential and commercial insurance agents who lead a women-owned family business. Karen has 37 years of industry experience and is known for her relatable style and high emotional intelligence. She proudly works with her daughter Katie, an emerging leader who has worked in the field for 11 years. Butterson Agency is a professional full-service agency offering a one-stop shop for personal (auto, homeowners, umbrella), commercial (general liability, workers comp.), and life insurance policies from over 20 carefully selected carriers.
Our clients work directly with our licensed professionals who care. We ensure reliable follow-up by answering questions quickly, leveraging our extensive network, and advocating on your behalf. We are independent brokers for a reason, so we ask you to give us a chance to review your current policy. We will make every effort to find the best coverage at a competitive price without sacrificing service. We will only switch your policy if it is the best thing for your family 100% of the time.
Welcome to Our Family
It matters when you work with Butterson Agency because it is our family business. We genuinely care about doing the right thing for our clients and welcome you to our family. We are a hometown business that believes in supporting our community.
Our Family Commitment
Give us a chance to review your current coverage, and we will make every effort to find the best coverage at a competitive price without sacrificing service. We will only switch your policy if it is the best thing for your family – #100% of the time.
Get Started Today
As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.
Get a Quote
Why Choose the Butterson Agency Family for You
What makes our independent agency different?
Reliable Follow-up
Ensuring reliable follow-up by answering questions quickly, leveraging our extensive network, and advocating on your behalf.
Comfortable Vibe
Creating a professional yet comfortable vibe with proactive communication, like we are speaking to our family.
Easy Processes
Educating our clients in layperson’s terms and making our processes easy.
Welcoming Office
Creating an open, homey, and welcoming office space that is full of life.
Insurance Solutions We Specialize In
We specialize in a variety of coverage options to meet your unique insurance needs.
Personal Insurance
Trusted advice and insurance solutions to protect what matters most.
Commercial Insurance
Coverage for businesses, retail service providers, manufacturers, and more.
Request an Insurance Quote
As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.
Get a Quote
It only takes a minute to get started.
- Fill out the form, we’ll be in touch.
- Go over your options with an agent.
- Get the coverage you need.
